Uganda’s Anti-Homosexual Bill
Homosexuality is illegal in Uganda. If the proposed Anti-Homosexuality Bill of 2009 gets passed, some Ugandan homosexuals could receive the death penalty. ABC News reports that “the bill creates a new category of crime called ‘Aggravated Homosexuality,’ which calls for death by hanging for gays or lesbians who have sex with anyone under 18 and for so-called ‘serial offenders.’ ” Additionally, the bill “calls for seven years in prison for ‘attempt to commit homosexuality,’ five years for landlords who knowingly house gays, three years for anyone, including parents, who fail to hand gay children over to the police within 24 hours and the extradition of gay Ugandans living abroad.” The bill has incited international outrage, with some countries threatening to withdraw aid from Uganda if the bill is passed into law. Within Uganda, activists reject the bill, saying it would force health and social workers to spy on and report their clients, Reuters Africa reports. Additionally, as AIDS activist Rtd Maj Rubaramira Ruranga told The Independent, “ ‘We’ll lose what we’ve achieved in the AIDS fight. . . . Gay infected patients will fear to go for treatment since the law requires the doctors to report the patient within 24 hours.’ ” According to The Monitor, a Ugandan newspaper, activists petitioning against the bill said it “ ‘goes against the Ugandan Constitution which promises freedom from discrimination on the grounds of sex, race, colour, ethnic origin, tribe, creed, birth or religion, social or economic standing, political opinion or disability. . . . We need laws to protect people, not ones that will humiliate, ridicule, prosecute and kill them en masse.’ ” The bill’s sponsor, David Bahati, defended the bill by saying that “in Uganda, 95 percent of our population does not support homosexuality.” As one gay Ugandan told Times Online, “ ‘they want to legislate us out of existence.’ ”
- If the bill is passed into law, what do you think will happen to homosexuals in Uganda?
- What can be done to prevent individuals from hating people who are different than they are?
- Bishop Christopher Senyojo told The Independent that “he would consider it unconscionable to report someone who approached him in his capacity as counselor on the grounds of the person’s sexuality. Yet his refusal to do so would make him vulnerable to prosecution and imprisonment.” What other conflicts of interest might the proposed bill cause? When do you think honoring human rights is more valuable than obeying authority?
- The Washington Post reports evangelical pastor Rick Warren’s response to Uganda’s anti-gay bill; Warren told Newsweek that “ ‘it is not my personal calling as a pastor in America to comment or interfere in the political process of other nations.’ ” The author of the article, Kathleen Parker, asks “is neutrality really an option for one of the world’s most powerful Christian leaders when state genocide of a minority is proposed in the name of Christianity? If we decide that genocide is too political for interference, then what good is moral leadership?” What does Parker mean by moral leadership? What do you think is the role of moral leadership? Why might a moral leader want to remain neutral on a controversial moral issue such as the anti-homosexual bill in Uganda? Do you think religious leaders have the right to remain neutral on such topics?
- AIDS activist Canon Gideon Byamugisha is quoted by The Independent as making an important distinction between criminal, and sinful—“what might be regarded in scripture and religious teaching as sinful, might fail to justifiably qualify as a crime.” What do you make of this statement?
- Ugandan journalist Moses Walugembe has been undergoing BBC WST mentoring “on political and human rights reporting” for the past six months. He told the BBC, “ ‘part of doing a successful programme is to have balance . . . but I know I can’t balance this issue because I wouldn’t be allowed to get the perspective of gay people or the people who support them.’ ” Why is freedom of speech important?
- As one gay Ugandan told Times Online, “ ‘They want to legislate us out of existence.’ ” Is it ever appropriate for a democracy to legislate a group out of existence?


